Goddamnit.
I am angry with one thing and one person: this movie and myself. The former for sucking balls and the latter for expecting great things from another failed movie-going venture.
I was intrigued by the concept of Button when I first saw previews for it: person born as an old man and ages backwards . Then I discovered that it was an adaptation of an F. Scott Fitzgerald short story and decided to read the story first. Then I received an illustrated, super-sweet hard back copy of the story as a Christmas present from a friend of mine two days later. Then I read the short story and loved it. Then I went with a couple friends on Christmas afternoon to see the film. Then I got angry.
It is a great story. Period. However, I read it all in probably half the time it took to sit through Brad Pitt’s three hour excursion. Now I’ve got nothing against long movies…Braveheart, The Dark Knight, Once Upon A Time in America, Heat, The Departed, Lord of The Rings Trilogy-the list of quality flicks clocking in at 2.5+ hours goes on and on…but this one kept going and going and going. Button attempted to be a sprawling and touching epic about this man’s life as he aged backwards-the things he saw, the way he experienced life, the losses he went through. The book succeeded; the movie failed.
To add insult to injury, director David Fincher (you might recognize his name from badass titles like Seven, The Game and Fight Club…so we know he’s capable) chose to have the story told in flashback form. The result is a dying woman and a daughter reading through Button’s journal during the onset of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans (where the movie…not the book…is also based). I don’t know who thought that would be a good idea, but it wasn’t. All it did was piss me off.
And of course, the main points of the movie were not in the book and the main points of the book were not in the movie.
Goddamnit.
S (story) = good basis but too flawed by the flashback storytelling and departure from original short story…5
A (acting) = Brad’s a good actor in my book but considering it was three hours of ONLY him…6
T (technical) = nothing to write home about…5
S A T cumulative = 5 6 5








After a queue-stalling two weeks of sitting on my coffee table, I finally got a chance to watch Amores Perros. I usually watch movies while I’m working on design projects, which isn’t really a good M.O. when I have to read subtitles.